Trading · Ed Seykota

Trend Rules You Can Live With

What would change if your rules were so simple you could sing them? Ed Seykota did exactly that. An MIT engineer who helped pioneer computerized trend following, he turned his whole method into a six-minute bluegrass tune. Press play, then write rules a tired you could still follow.

Ed Seykota — The Whipsaw Song (© 2008 Ed Seykota; official TradingTribe channel, 6:28). Seykota introduces it himself, then plays it with members of the Northern Nevada Bluegrass Association, one verse per rule. Video hosted on YouTube; not uploaded to Premier Sol.

Watch for these moments (one verse per rule):
  • 0:00 — Seykota’s intro: the “essential elements” of his trend trading system, delivered with a grin.
  • 0:49 — The chorus: you get a whip and I get a saw… one good trend pays for ’em all.
  • 1:04 — Ride your winners: catch a trend, ride it to the end.
  • 1:52 — Cut your losses: give that loss a toss.
  • 2:38 — Manage your risk: how you know your risk is right — you can sleep at night.
  • 3:24 — Use stops: when price breaks through, the stops are already in, so there is nothing to do.
  • 4:13 — Stick to the system: the drawdown gets bigger, you stick to the plan and pull the trigger.
  • 5:00 — File the news: the hot news flash goes in the trash.

Below is our Crew study guide — original teaching. Short quotes are attributed; we do not paste long copyrighted book text. Education only, not financial advice.

1

Who he is, and why traders still study him

Ed Seykota earned two degrees at MIT in 1969, electrical engineering and management. Around 1970, while working at a brokerage, he used early punch-card computers to test trend-following rules, building on Richard Donchian’s moving-average work. He kept a low profile until Jack Schwager gave him a chapter in Market Wizards (1989), titled “Everybody Gets What They Want.” Michael Marcus, another trader in that book, credits Seykota as a big early influence. In 1992 Seykota started the Trading Tribe, groups of traders who meet to work on the feelings that override their rules.

2

Cut losses. Cut losses. Cut losses.

Seykota’s best-known line puts all three “elements of good trading” on the same idea. A small loss is just a fee. A loss you refuse to take can become the one that takes you out of the game. Decide where you are wrong before you enter, put the stop in, and let it do the work. Then when price breaks through, as the song says, there is nothing to do.

“The elements of good trading are: (1) cutting losses, (2) cutting losses, and (3) cutting losses. If you can follow these three rules, you may have a chance.” — Ed Seykota, in Jack Schwager’s Market Wizards (1989)
3

Ride winners, and keep bets small

Trend following often means many small losses and a few big winners. That is why the chorus says one good trend pays for ’em all. Two habits make it work. First, let the winner run; do not grab a quick profit because you are scared to give it back. Second, keep each bet small enough that a run of whipsaws does not hurt you, so you are still in the game when the big trend shows up. In Market Wizards he gave his rules as: cut losses, ride winners, keep bets small, follow the rules without question, and know when to break the rules.

4

Follow the rules, and know when to break them

The last two rules sound like opposites, and that is on purpose. Most of the time, discipline means following the plan when the drawdown gets bigger and the news gets loud. Breaking a rule is a rare decision you make with a clear head, not a mood that hits halfway through a trade. Seykota also told Schwager the trick is to build a system you are actually compatible with. A rule you can live with beats a smart rule you will drop.

“Systems don’t need to be changed. The trick is for a trader to develop a system with which he is compatible.” — Ed Seykota, in Market Wizards (1989)
5

Everybody gets what they want

This is Seykota’s hardest idea, and the reason the Trading Tribe exists. He says results show what a trader really wants, which is not always what they say they want. Someone who keeps moving stops may want to feel right more than they want to make money. Someone who trades every headline may want the thrill. Look at your last ten decisions honestly. They tell you what you have been choosing.

“Win or lose, everybody gets what they want out of the market.” — Ed Seykota, in Market Wizards (1989)
Study guide

Try this week

Short prompts. Honest answers. Move once.

  1. Cut: Write your cut-loss rule in one line. Where is your stop before you click?
  2. Ride: Write your hold-the-winner rule in one line. What, and only what, gets you out of a trade that is working?
  3. Size: How many losses in a row could you take at your current size and still follow the plan calmly?
  4. Want: Look at your last ten trades or big money decisions. What did you actually want each time?
  5. Sing it: Shrink your whole plan into one verse a tired you could still follow. Post it in the Crew if you are brave.
  6. Travel parallel: Same rules, different market. Set your budget and your walk-away point before you browse stays this week.

Ready for the next lesson — and the next deal drop?

Join free on Telegram or Discord. Learn with the Crew, then browse stays when the picture is clear.